• Home
  • Videos
  • Signup for Emails
  • What You Can Do
  • About True Dignity
    • About the Board
    • Contact Us
  • Links
  • Report Abuse

True Dignity Vermont

Vermont Citizens Against Assisted Suicide

Suicide is never death with dignity, and assisted suicide legislation threatens true patient choices at the end of life.

Feeds:
Posts
« Bad But Not Hopeless News From Canada: Good News from Colorado
A Deep and Tragic Irony: In VT Lawmakers Praise Suicide Prevention Efforts While Legally Enabling Suicide »

Vermont’s Suicide Conflict of Interest

 

February 12, 2015 by Administrators

Two stories were in the Vermont news this week that highlight a very real conflict of interest over suicide in this State.

Vermont Public Radio aired an interview with JoEllen Tarallo-Falk, Director of the Vermont Suicide Prevention Center (VTSPC), on suicide prevention: http://digital.vpr.net/post/more-funding-needed-suicide-prevention-advocates-say

Meanwhile, several media outlets published stories glamorizing two recent Legislature-endorsed (per Act 39, “Physician Aid-in-Dying”) suicides in Vermont, which have been promoted as part of a public relations push by proponents of Act 39, to gain support for the law. The effort is fueled by an acknowledgment of serious deficiencies in the law which proponents see as roadblocks to getting support from physicians, nursing homes and pharmacists, and which they erroneously claim can be fixed with a few changes.

In the VPR interview, Tarallo-Falk said that the VTSPC will be asking the Legislature for funding of $750,000 to help support ongoing suicide prevention efforts. She reported an alarming increase in the number of suicides in the last 10 years in Vermont, whose suicide rate is well above the national average. Thanks in part to federal funding, an aggressive effort to deal with the problem and to identify people at risk for suicide has included the training of over 1400 individuals and outreach to numerous schools and institutions throughout the State. The federal funding will soon end and the VTSPC hopes new State funding can come from Education, Health Care and Human Services budgets.

The efforts of the VTSPC are commendable and to be supported. But their request poses a conflict of interest for the Legislature. To promote suicide prevention treatment for some groups while at the same time supporting suicide for one significant and vulnerable population—those who have terminal illnesses—is discrimination of the worst kind. But the reality is that the attitude toward the terminally ill in Vermont has already shifted to one of “helping” them kill themselves, rather than evaluating whether suicide prevention efforts might help them live out their lives in comfort and a state of positive mental health.

Studies reveal that among the elderly, a key reason for suicide is chronic pain. Because the proponents of assisted suicide have worked hard to use the fear of pain as a justification for assisted suicide, it is not hard to imagine that any elderly person with a chronic condition may receive a referral for “aid in dying” rather than suicide prevention treatment, along with better pain management, that might be of greater ultimate help to that person.

Tarallo-Falk noted that economic worries and concerns about being able to adequately care for loved ones is a key factor among some populations at risk for suicide. It is easy to imagine that a person with a terminal illness, or an elderly person in frail health, might also worry about the depletion of financial resources related to his care; does this person merit suicide prevention treatment, or a prescription to kill himself? Who decides?

According to the VTSPC, another factor that increases a person’s risk of suicide, is being related to someone who has died by suicide. Act 39 cannot change the definition of suicide by merely giving it another name. We must acknowledge the risk and reality of suicide contagion as a direct result of this law, and as a result of each glamorized media portrayal of its use. The Centers for Disease Control long ago cautioned the media against romanticizing suicide because doing so may contribute to suicide contagion (http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00031539.htm).  The existence of suicide clusters is well known and reported, and counselors are routinely sent into schools in which a student has committed suicide to try to offset the possibility of suicide contagion.

In Oregon, where assisted suicide has been legal since 1998, the suicide rate among all populations has risen steadily, raising concerns about suicide contagion. The rate of non-assisted suicides in the state, which had been declining for a decade prior to legalization of assisted suicide, immediately began to rise.  It has continued to do so.  In 2010 it was 35% over the national average (http://www.oregon.gov/DHS/news/2010news/2010-0909a.pdf.  By 2012, it was 41% over the national average (https://www.deschutes.org/DeschutesOrg/files/33/33d5338f-6e71-49ca-b6fa-051ac3293a8b.pdf).

Similarly, Washington State legalized assisted suicide in March 2009, five and a half years ago.  Now we read that the non-assisted suicide rate is rising there as well. (http://mifflin.pa.networkofcare.org/mh/news-article-detail.aspx?id=54947).

We already know that Vermont’s suicide rate is alarming. Do we really wish to work against valid efforts to decrease it?

The distinction between people whose situations call for “suicide prevention intervention” and those whose expressed desire to die leads to a prescription to die, will become increasingly arbitrary, and the decision to treat may well come down to the subjective judgment of people other than the person who is sick.

Adding safeguards to Act 39 will not solve these and numerous other problems inherent in the Law. No additions or changes to Act 39 can ever make it free of risk from abuse and error. Abuse and error that result in death, which is final, cannot be tolerated.

Suicide prevention is a laudable cause which we should all support. Act 39 is a dangerous piece of legislation which should be repealed.

 

 

Share this:

  • Click to email this to a friend
  • Share on Facebook
  • Click to share on Google+
  • Click to share on Twitter
  • More
  • Click to print
  • Click to share on Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit
  • Click to share on Pocket
  • Click to share on StumbleUpon

Related

Posted in Selling of Suicide, Suicide Contagion, Suicide Increase, Vermont Legislature | Leave a Comment



  • facebook  YouTube-social-squircle_red  Twitter
  • Menu

    • Home
    • Videos
    • Signup for Emails
    • What You Can Do
    • About True Dignity
      • About the Board
      • Contact Us
    • Links
    • Report Abuse
  • Stay Active!

    • Get Action Alerts Emails
    • Make Calls
    • Write Letters
  • Stay Informed!

    • Join our email list
  • Vermont Government

    • Governor Peter Shumlin
    • Lt. Governor Phil Scott
    • State Reps By District
    • State Senators By District
    • VT Legislative Directory
  • Article Categories

    • Ablism (2)
    • Acceptance of Unintended Consequences (5)
    • Action Alert (3)
    • Administrative (4)
    • Agism (4)
    • Alerts (24)
    • Animal euthanasia argument (4)
    • Board (1)
    • Brittany Maynard (1)
    • Canada (3)
    • Canada Supreme Court (1)
    • Cheapness of Assisted Suicide (4)
    • Choice Becomes "Duty" to Die (11)
    • Chronic Diseases Rendered Terminal by Non-treatment (3)
    • Classism and Assisted Suicide (5)
    • Colorado (2)
    • Commentary (27)
    • Compassion and Choices (7)
    • Conflict of Interest (3)
    • Connecticut (2)
    • Connecticut (2)
    • Connecticut (2)
    • Conscience Rights (1)
    • Cost Cutting Agenda of Barbara Coombs Lee (2)
    • Countering the PAS lobby (1)
    • CT (1)
    • Damage to Family (3)
    • Damage to Helpers (1)
    • Death with Dignity (3)
    • Defeats in other states (7)
    • Depression (7)
    • Devaluation of Lives with Disabilities (33)
    • Disability Rights Groups' Opposition (30)
    • Doctor's Power (2)
    • Dying with Real Dignity (1)
    • Editorials (5)
    • Elder Abuse (22)
    • Election 2014 (3)
    • Error Possibility (2)
    • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Contagion (3)
    • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Two Sides of the Same Coin (8)
    • Exemption options (4)
    • Expansion of Assisted Suicide/Euthanasia (14)
    • Georgia (3)
    • Germany (1)
    • Healthy people helped to commit suicide (2)
    • Language manipulation (3)
    • Legal Opinions (7)
    • Legislative Efforts in Other Countries (3)
    • Legislative Efforts in Other States (9)
    • Legislative Testimony (1)
    • Letters to the Editors of Newspapers (13)
    • Letters to the Legislature (2)
    • Maryland (1)
    • Massachusetts (3)
    • Medical Opinions (18)
    • Medical Power (5)
    • Medical Societies (4)
    • Montana (2)
    • Moratorium (2)
    • Murder Invitation (2)
    • Nevada (1)
    • Nevada (1)
    • Never Investigated (1)
    • New Jersey (5)
    • New York (1)
    • Not a Peaceful Death (4)
    • Oregon (4)
    • Other Countries (2)
    • Other Countries (1)
    • Other States (7)
    • Other states (4)
    • Out of State/General (10)
    • Palliative Care (6)
    • Personal Stories (5)
    • Pharmacists (6)
    • Polls (4)
    • Pro Assisted Suicide (1)
    • Prognosis Inaccuracy (2)
    • Racism and Assisted Suicide (1)
    • Randy Brock (1)
    • Rationing (3)
    • Reasons to Oppose (3)
    • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in Other Countries (3)
    • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in other states (5)
    • Relatives Won't Know (3)
    • Religious "movement" (1)
    • Repeal Effort (4)
    • Richard Doerflinger (1)
    • Selfishness of Proponents (3)
    • Selling of Suicide (5)
    • Silencing Opposition (2)
    • Slippery Slope (23)
    • Suicide Contagion (20)
    • Suicide Increase (9)
    • Suicide Tourism (3)
    • Talking Points (2)
    • Testimony before non-VT legislative bodies (3)
    • Transparency Lack (1)
    • True Dignity (22)
    • Uncategorized (342)
    • Unused Drug Dangers (1)
    • Unworkability if Regulations Attempt to Make AS "Safe" (1)
    • Updates (1)
    • US (1)
    • Vermont (12)
    • Vermont (5)
    • Vermont Alliance for Ethical Health Care (3)
    • Vermont Governor (4)
    • Vermont Legislature (61)
    • Videos (24)
    • Vote Count on Passage (4)
    • Vote Results (5)

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.